Why examiners distrust rehearsed speeches but reward rehearsed structure
Apr 14, 2026
Candidates sometimes memorise speeches to feel prepared. In exams, this often sounds artificial and inflexible.
“Scripts sound polished. Structure sounds safe.” - A/Prof George Eskander
Why scripts fail
Scripts fail when:
- the case changes
- examiners interrupt
- time runs short
- red flags appear
- new information emerges
Structure adapts. Scripts collapse.
What structure allows
Structure allows candidates to:
- adapt safely
- prioritise dynamically
- respond to examiner cues
- maintain clarity
- demonstrate judgment
Conclusion
Exams reward adaptable structure, not rigid scripts. Preparation should focus on frameworks, not speeches.
Reference
Schmidt HG, Rikers RM. How expertise develops in medicine. Academic Medicine. 2007.
